PayHOA and AffordableHOA are both legitimate platforms built for self-managed HOAs. If you're evaluating both, that's a good starting point: you've already eliminated the enterprise software that isn't designed for volunteer boards. The question is which one fits your community better.
This comparison is written by AffordableHOA, so you should weigh that context. We've tried to be genuinely fair about where PayHOA is the right choice, because recommending a platform that doesn't fit your community helps no one. The honest answer is that the decision often comes down to community size and whether flat-fee or per-unit pricing works out better for you.
Both platforms publish their pricing. AffordableHOA uses 5 flat tiers covering 1-1,000 units. PayHOA uses 8 narrower bands plus a per-unit tier above 500 units. AffordableHOA is cheaper at every comparable band, and every feature is included regardless of plan.
| Community Size | AffordableHOA | PayHOA | Savings |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1-50 units | $49/mo | $54-$65/mo | $5-$16/mo |
| 51-150 units | $99/mo | $109-$142/mo | $10-$43/mo |
| 151-300 units | $179/mo | $186-$219/mo | $7-$40/mo |
| 301-500 units | $239/mo | $252-$275/mo | $13-$36/mo |
| 501-1,000 units | $0.50/unit ($250 min) | $0.55/unit ($275 min) | ~10% less |
Note: PayHOA also charges per-payment ACH fees ($2.45 per payment) and card fees (3.5% + $0.50) on top of the subscription price. AffordableHOA passes Stripe Connect fees directly to your HOA's account with no markup. Verify current pricing at payhoa.com before making a decision. The figures above are based on PayHOA's published pricing as of May 2026.
The math is clear across every band. AffordableHOA is priced below PayHOA at every tier. The best approach is to compare published pricing from both platforms at your unit count and factor in which feature set better fits your board's workflow.
Both platforms cover the core HOA management features that most self-managed boards need. Here's how they compare across the major categories:
| Feature | AffordableHOA | PayHOA |
|---|---|---|
| Online dues collection | Yes (Stripe Connect) | Yes |
| Autopay for residents | Yes | Yes |
| ACH (bank transfer) payments | Yes | Yes |
| Dues deposit directly to HOA bank | Yes (Stripe Connect) | Yes |
| Resident portal | Yes | Yes |
| Google Sign-In for residents | Yes | No (email/password) |
| Violation tracking with photos | Yes | Yes |
| Maintenance request tracking | Yes | Yes |
| Architectural change requests | Yes | Yes |
| Email announcements | Yes | Yes |
| Document storage | Yes | Yes |
| Community polls / voting | Yes | Yes |
| Automatic late fees | Yes | Yes |
| Expense tracking | Yes | Yes |
| Recurring expenses (auto-posted) | Yes | Yes |
| Bank reconciliation | Yes | Yes (higher tiers) |
| Reserve fund planning | Yes, with 30-year forecast | Limited |
| Budget forecasting | Yes, scenario modeling | Yes |
| 1099 vendor summary | Yes | Yes |
| QuickBooks export | Yes | Yes |
| Amenity / facility booking | Yes | No |
| Document e-signatures | Yes | No |
| AI assistant for residents | Yes, 24/7 | No |
| Vendor compliance (COI, license tracking) | Yes | Limited |
| Encrypted board notes | Yes | No |
| Community manager role (no billing access) | Yes | Yes |
| Full double-entry general ledger | No | Yes (higher tiers) |
| Dedicated mobile app | No (mobile web) | Yes |
| Free trial | 14 days, no card | Yes |
| Contract | Month-to-month | Month-to-month |
This comparison would not be honest without acknowledging where PayHOA has an edge:
PayHOA's higher tiers include a full double-entry general ledger with accrual accounting. AffordableHOA covers the full self-managed workflow, including bank reconciliation, expense tracking, reserve fund planning, and QuickBooks export, but does not offer a built-in double-entry general ledger. If your board wants all bookkeeping handled inside one platform without exporting to QuickBooks or working with a CPA, PayHOA has more depth in that specific area.
PayHOA offers iOS and Android apps. AffordableHOA's resident portal is mobile-responsive but browser-based. For residents who prefer an app icon on their phone home screen, PayHOA has a UX advantage there.
For very large communities, it is worth comparing current pricing from both platforms directly. Both use flat-fee tiers, and the gap between them changes at different unit counts. AffordableHOA scales up to 1,000 units.
PayHOA has been in the market longer and has a larger existing user base. If you value a larger community of users who share knowledge and workarounds, that's a real consideration.
AffordableHOA is priced below PayHOA at every published tier, and every feature is included regardless of plan level. A 300-unit community pays $179/month versus $219/month with PayHOA, a $480/year difference. A 500-unit community pays $239/month versus $275/month, saving $432/year. Above 500 units the advantage compounds further on the per-unit rate.
AffordableHOA includes vendor compliance management: tracking contractor certificates of insurance, license expiration dates, and setting automatic alerts before documents lapse. For communities that work with multiple vendors, this prevents the board from unknowingly allowing an uninsured contractor on the property. PayHOA's vendor management is more limited in this area.
Sensitive board notes in AffordableHOA are encrypted at rest using Fernet encryption. This is a meaningful security feature for boards that document sensitive matters like executive session discussions or personnel notes in software. PayHOA does not offer equivalent note encryption.
Resident portal adoption is a real challenge for most HOAs. AffordableHOA supports Google Sign-In, which eliminates the friction of creating and remembering yet another password. In communities where most residents use Gmail, adoption rates are meaningfully higher.
AffordableHOA's 14-day trial requires no credit card. You can fully evaluate the platform before entering any payment information. This is a small thing but it reflects a different relationship with the trial: you should try it because it's useful, not because you forgot to cancel.
You want per-unit flat-tier pricing with every feature included at every plan level; you want vendor compliance tracking built in; you value encrypted note storage; you prefer Google Sign-In for residents; or you want to try before entering a credit card number.
You need a full accounting general ledger without a separate accounting tool; or your residents strongly prefer a native mobile app over a mobile-optimized web portal.
Both platforms offer free trials. The most reliable way to make the decision is to run both trials simultaneously with your actual community data and see which one your board members find easier to use. Whichever one the board actually adopts and uses consistently is the right choice.
For a broader view of what's available, see the full HOA management software comparison for 2026, which covers six platforms including enterprise options.
Every feature included. No setup fees. Try free for 14 days.
Start Free Trial